Columbus Crew thrashed Inter Miami 3-0 in Game 1 of the MLS Cup Playoffs at Nu Stadium on Saturday, leaving Lionel Messi’s side one defeat away from an early exit.

Gonzalo Tapia scored twice for the visitors. The Chilean opened the scoring from the penalty spot in the ninth minute after Miami goalkeeper Dayne St. Clair raced off his line and brought him down, and he added his second in the 58th minute after turning Yannick Bright and running clear to score. Taha Habroune made it 2-0 in between, finishing Brais Méndez’s through ball across St. Clair in the 52nd minute.

Miami were architects of much of their own downfall. St. Clair’s unpressured error gave Columbus the early lead, and defender Gonzalo Luján was sent off in the 36th minute for a second yellow card, leaving the hosts down to 10 men for most of the game. Miami still created chances — Messi was spectacularly denied by United States goalkeeper Patrick Schulte, and Luis Suárez poked a shot just wide of the post with the goal at his mercy — but they reached half-time only 1-0 down and were punished ruthlessly after the break.

The night also brought a flashpoint involving Messi. In first-half stoppage time, the Argentine took a quick throw-in straight into the face of Tapia from a couple of feet away after Tapia had not backed off the required distance, and referee Allen Chapman booked both players. Columbus head coach Laurent Courtois said afterwards that Messi should have been sent off. “Everyone knows that was more than a yellow card,” Courtois told reporters. Had Messi been dismissed, he would have been suspended for Game 2.

Miami head coach Cristian “Kily” González pointed to the red card as the turning point. “The team created four or five clear-cut chances to put the game away, but we couldn’t convert, and their goalkeeper made the saves,” González told reporters. “Then came the red card, which completely changed the nature of the match.” He added: “I take full responsibility.”

The result was a major upset on paper. Miami finished the regular season as the No. 2 seed in the Eastern Conference, 13 points ahead of seventh-seeded Columbus, but the Crew were the form team in the league — they were bottom of the East on 1 September and won their final six regular-season games to reach the postseason. Miami, by contrast, have won only five of their last 18 MLS games, and Saturday was the first time they had failed to score at Nu Stadium.

Before kickoff, Miami co-owner Jorge Mas presented Messi with the 2026 Golden Boot. The Argentine scored 26 goals in the regular season, with 17 assists, and became the first player to win the league’s scoring award in back-to-back seasons. It counted for little on the night.

Miami must now win Game 2 on Friday in Columbus to force a deciding Game 3 back in Miami on 2 December. “Inter Miami always plays to win and we know if we lose the next game we are out. So, that’s the pressure,” said Miami’s Brazilian defender-midfielder Casemiro. “The most important thing now is to be calm. We know we have to do better, because we can do better.”