Liverpool should have been awarded a penalty during their 1-0 defeat by Arsenal at Anfield on 1 November, the Premier League’s Key Match Incidents (KMI) panel has ruled, after Jurriën Timber pulled Alexander Isak’s shirt inside the area.
The independent panel voted 4-1 that a penalty should have been given on the field for Timber’s challenge on the Sweden striker. Three of the five panel members also felt VAR Stuart Attwell should have intervened. The on-field decision stood at the time, with VAR choosing not to send the incident for review. The panel was unanimous, however, that Timber should not have been sent off, ruling Isak was not in a position to take a shot on goal in the immediate term, so the challenge did not deny an obvious goal-scoring opportunity.
The KMI panel is an independent body made up of three former players or coaches, one Premier League representative and one representative of referees’ body PGMOL. It reviews the key incidents from every round of Premier League fixtures and publishes its verdicts on whether the on-field decision — and any VAR involvement — was correct.
Bournemouth head coach Andoni Iraola said: “There is a clear grab of the shirt and a clear pull. I was very surprised that VAR didn’t decide the action was clear and obvious.” Former Arsenal striker Ian Wright added: “We are watching this and we are saying, ‘How can you not give that?’ The shirt pull has delayed Isak’s run. The reason he didn’t get there is because of the pull.”
The ruling is only the second time this season the panel has found VAR failed to intervene on an incorrect on-field decision. The other case came on 31 October, when the panel ruled Ipswich Town should have had a penalty after Moussa Mendy held Jacob O’Shea. Across the season so far, the panel has delivered 196 verdicts, deeming 86% of on-field decisions correct — a figure that rises to 97% once VAR intervention is taken into account.
The panel also backed the decision to take no action against Arsenal’s Noni Madueke for his aerial challenge on Alexis Mac Allister in the same match, judging the contact “negligible” and Mac Allister’s reaction “clearly exaggerated”. Both incidents were reviewed as part of the panel’s regular round-up of the weekend’s fixtures.
The incident came in a match Arsenal won 1-0 at Anfield, Kai Havertz’s 16th-minute goal ending the Gunners’ 14-year wait for a Premier League victory at the ground. The result itself stands — the panel’s verdict changes nothing about the points — but it will add to the scrutiny of VAR decisions in big games. Liverpool return to Premier League action at home to Manchester United on 22 November, when Arne Slot’s side will look to bounce back from the Arsenal defeat, while the KMI panel will publish its next verdicts after the following round of fixtures.




