FC Cincinnati beat Orlando City 3-1 and Real Salt Lake edged Seattle Sounders 4-2 on penalties as the two MLS Cup playoffs wild-card ties were decided on Thursday night.

At Inter&Co Stadium in Orlando, Florida, Martín Ojeda opened the scoring in the 26th minute for the hosts, but goals from Evander and Samuel Gidi turned the game around for the visitors. Cincinnati will now face Nashville SC in the best-of-three first round of the playoffs.

Orlando's night ended in further disappointment when striker Daryl Dike, introduced in the 75th minute, was injured moments later. Interim head coach Martín Perelman said he did not know exactly what was wrong. “I don't know what the issue is,” he said, adding that he believed it was “something with his hamstring” but stressing he was not certain. Despite the apparent injury, Dike stayed on the pitch for the rest of the game because Orlando had no substitution windows left.

Perelman defended his substitutions, saying nobody expects a player to come on with 15 minutes left and then get injured, and that it was simply another piece of misfortune in the match. He said the group were very disappointed not to bring happiness to the fans at the stadium, but added that the effort had been there even if it was not enough, and backed his players to bring happiness and achievements to the club in future.

It was another cruel setback for Dike, whose recent seasons have been wrecked by injury: a season-ending hamstring injury in 2022, a right Achilles tendon rupture in 2023, a left Achilles tendon rupture in 2024, and a thigh problem that kept him out for 10 matches at the start of the 2025/26 season. The defeat ended Orlando's season in Antoine Griezmann's first season with the club.

In the night's other tie, Real Salt Lake won 4-2 on penalties at Seattle Sounders after a 1-1 draw at Lumen Field. Albert Rusnák gave Seattle the lead in the 36th minute, and Morgan Guilavogui equalised in the 63rd, before the visitors won the shootout to advance. Dejan Joveljic and Rusnák both had penalties saved in the shootout, while Real Salt Lake converted all four of theirs.

Thursday's results settled the wild-card round, with Cincinnati and Real Salt Lake joining the teams already through to the best-of-three first round. Cincinnati's reward is a series against Nashville, the top seed in the Eastern Conference, while Real Salt Lake advance to the next round of the playoffs.